Having made her name as a true-crime podcaster 20 years earlier on the back of the Warren Cave case, Poppy Scoville-Parnell (Octavia Spencer) finds herself revisiting the crime when new evidence comes to light.
The violent murder of writer and academic Chuck Buhrman in his suburban LA home resulted in the conviction of teenage Cave, next-door neighbour. Yet newly released video evidence suggests the testimony provided by daughter Lanie Buhrman immediately after the death is different to that given in court. A motion for a retrial is dismissed but Poppy’s interest is piqued.
Over eight episodes, a plodding narrative unfolds that explores events of that fateful Hallowe’en night 20 years earlier. Recognising mistakes were made in her original reportage, Poppy looks to make amends. But with Cave (Aaron Paul) now covered in prison swastika tattoos, it’s a challenge.
A deeply manipulative and unlikeable Poppy wants the truth – and she will mould what she wants to believe to fit that end. A single-minded podcaster followed circumstantial evidence 20 years ago resulting in contributing to the incarceration of an innocent man. Truth be Told shows Poppy to have failed to learn by experience as she alienates not only the Buhrman and Cave family members, but her own father and sisters, as well as husband, Ingram (Michael Beach).
Subtle it’s not as Octavia Spencer fails wholeheartedly to set the right tone for an emotionless, expressiveless dullard – not helped by a pedantic script.
Rating: 40%