Through the telling of a single story, director Edward Zwick looks to the enactment of the death penalty in Texas and the many resulting miscarriages of justice.
Having spent 12 years in prison for the murder of his three young daughters, Cameron Todd Willingham (Jack O’Connell) was executed in spite of scientific evidence and expert testimony supporting his claims of innocence. Tried and sentenced in his home town, the philandering, wife-beating Willingham was deeply unpopular, reflected in the travesty of a trial. It’s only years after the trial and prior to his execution, when writer Laura Dern starts to visit him, does the truth start to come out.
A film of two halves, Trial By Fire at its best is a well-paced family tragedy/courtroom drama but which loses impetus as the narrative settles into a (predictable) determination by Dern to see justice – even at the expense of alienating her own teenage children. O’Donnell is excellent as the wronged inmate but the film ultimately settles into an unsubtle crusade against the death penalty.
Rating: 50%
Director: Edward Zwick (The Last Samurai, Love & Other Drugs)
Writer: Geoffrey Fletcher (Precious, Violet & Daisy) – based on The New Yorker article by David Grann
Main cast: Laura Dern (Marriage Story, Wild), Jack O’Connell (’71, Money Monster), Emily Meade (Money Monster, TV’s The Deuce)
An Opinion or Two 